Best Restaurants in Staten Island (Your 2025 Guide)
Let’s be honest—Staten Island doesn’t always get credit when people talk about New York food. But skip it, and you’ll miss out. This borough has serious flavor, no pretense, and portions that won’t leave you hunting for snacks later. From pizza joints older than your cousin’s first iPod to spots where pasta rules the table, the best restaurants in Staten Island serve up more than you’d expect. You just need to know where to go—and luckily, that’s what we’re here for.
Best Restaurants in Staten Island (2025) | Where to Eat in New York City’s Underrated Borough
Osteria Santina
Behind an unassuming exterior, Osteria Santina serves Italian dishes that feel like they came straight from a family kitchen. The flavors are rich, simple, and don’t try too hard. It’s the kind of spot where you can settle in for a long dinner or stop in for a quick bite and still leave full.
- Cuisine: Italian
- Website: https://osteriasantina.com
- Email: info@osteriasantina.com
- Location: 02 Jewett Ave, Staten Island
- Phone: 1 718-448-6100
- Price: $-$$
Blue
Not far away, Blue brings together Mediterranean and American flavors by the waterfront. The outdoor seating works well on a nice day, and the cocktails hold their own. It’s easygoing and doesn’t overcomplicate things—just solid food in a laid-back space.
- Cuisine: American
- Website: https://bluerestaurantnyc.com
- Location: 1115 Richmond Ter, Staten Island
- Phone: 1 718-273-7777
- Price: $$
Bocelli
For those leaning toward a more traditional sit-down meal, Bocelli keeps it polished without being stiff. The staff moves with ease, the pasta dishes are consistent, and the setting works for both casual nights out and small celebrations.
- Cuisine: Italian
- Reservation: Click here.
- Website: www.osteriabocelli.com
- Location: 1250 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island
- Phone: 1 718-420-6150
- Price: $$
Beso
Adding Spanish flavors to the mix, Beso keeps things relaxed with shareable plates and sangria. The atmosphere stays warm, especially during happy hour, when the tables fill up with people catching up over tapas. It’s one of those spots that gets busier the longer you stay.
- Cuisine: Spanish
- Website: https://besonyc.com
- Location: 70 Bay St, Staten Island
- Phone: 1 718-816-8162
- Price: $-$$
Trattoria Oliveto
Stepping into Trattoria Oliveto feels like a refresh of the old-school Italian trattoria. The menu hits familiar notes—think pastas, sauces, and comfort food—but the space brings a more modern touch. It’s a clean setup without too much fuss.
- Cuisine: Italian
- Website:https://olivetonyc.com
- Email: olivetonyc@gmail.com
- Location: 1642 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island
- Phone: 1 347-466-5556
- Price: $-$$
Lorenzo’s Restaurant, Bar & Cabaret
A steady presence since 2001, Lorenzo’s Restaurant, Bar & Cabaret leans on its long-running staff and loyal customer base. The meals stay consistent, the bar stays busy, and the atmosphere reflects years of service and familiar faces.
- Cuisine: Italian
- Website: https://lorenzosdining.com
- Location: 1100 South Ave, Staten Island
- Phone: 1 718-477-2400 ext. 4
- Price: $-$$
Marina Cafe Restaurant & Tiki Bar
Right by Great Kills Harbor, Marina Cafe has been serving Staten Island for over 40 years. The water views set the mood, but the focus is on seafood, solid portions, and reliable service. It also doubles as an event space for those looking to host without going far.
- Cuisine: Seafood
- Website: https://marinacafesiny.com
- Location: 154 Mansion Ave, Staten Island
- Phone: 1 718-967-3077
- Price: $-$$
Pastavino
With a focus on pasta and wine, Pastavino draws in diners who want a full table without extra noise. The house-made pastas pair well with a wine list that covers a wide range of Italian regions. It stays casual, even as the food shows a lot of thought.
- Cuisine: Italian
- Reservation: Click here.
- Website: www.pastavinosi.com
- Location: 44 Navy Pier Ct, Staten Island
- Phone: 1 718-556-9300
- Price: $-$$
Mansion
Bringing a newer energy to the borough, Mansion offers a straightforward menu rooted in Italian-American comfort. It feels like a return to the family restaurant model—simple service, familiar faces, and large plates meant to be shared.
- Cuisine: Italian
- Reservation: Click here.
- Website: https://mansion.restaurant
- Email: info@mansion.restaurant
- Location: 141 Mansion Ave, Staten Island
- Phone: 1 718-605-9200
- Price: $-$$
Deluca’s Italian Restaurant
At Deluca’s Italian Restaurant, family ties run deep. The food sticks to tradition, and the atmosphere reflects that same mindset—no gimmicks, just the kind of cooking that fits any day of the week.
- Cuisine: Italian
- Reservation: Click here.
- Website: www.delucasitalian.com
- Location: 7324 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
- Phone: 1 718-227-7200
- Price: $-$$
Fiore Di Mare
On the far end of the island, Fiore Di Mare rounds out the lineup with a quiet approach and a menu that balances old and new. It’s not trying to be flashy, and that’s what makes it work.
- Cuisine: Italian
- Reservation: Click here.
- Website: www.fioredimaresi.com
- Email: info@fioredm.com
- Location: 227 Mansion Ave, Staten Island
- Phone: 1 718-227-9771
- Price: $$
More…