20+ Bars & Restaurants with Fireplaces in NYC (2025 Guide)

Look, NYC winter is no joke. That wind whips down the avenue, and your apartment radiator just isn’t cutting it. You need a real escape, which means finding legit bars and restaurants with a fireplace in New York City.

Just a heads up, hours and menus change faster than the L train schedule. Always check their official site before you trek across town.

The Coziest Bars and Restaurants with a Fireplace in New York City

The Waverly Inn

If you want that iconic, “main character in a movie” New York winter, this is the spot. This West Village institution is famously hard to get into, but the two fireplaces and old-school charm are top-tier. Yes, you might actually see a celebrity.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine: American 
• Location: 16 Bank St, New York
• Contact: www.waverlynyc.com | (917) 828-1154
• Pro Tip: Reservations are everything and they’re booked way out. Your best bet is to set a reminder for 30 days out or try to slide in on a random Tuesday. Don’t just show up.

Clover Club

This Cobble Hill spot is a classic for a reason. The cocktails are serious, but the move in winter is the back room. It’s got the fireplace, plush seats, and a vibe that’s perfect for a date where you can actually hear each other.

• Price: $$
• Cuisine: Cocktail Bar
• Location: 210 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY
• Contact: www.cloverclubny.com
• Pro Tip: It gets packed. Go early if you’re serious about getting that fireplace spot, especially on a weekend.

The Brandy Library

If you’re looking for a grown-up spot, this is it. This TriBeCa bar is quiet, lined with endless bottles, and the fireplace just adds to the “I’m sophisticated” vibe. Great for a real conversation over some incredible spirits.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine:  Bar
• Location: 25 N Moore St Frnt 1, New York 
• Contact: www.brandylibrary.com | (212) 226-5545 | info@brandylibrary.com
• Pro Tip: Don’t get paralyzed by the novel they call a menu. The staff actually knows their stuff and won’t make you feel dumb. Just ask for a recommendation.

Molly’s

Sometimes you just want a real pub. Molly’s in Gramercy is one of the most legit Irish pubs in the city, right down to the sawdust on the floor and a real wood-burning fireplace. It’s zero-percent pretentious and feels like a time warp.

• Price: $$
• Cuisine: Irish Pub
• Location: 287 3rd Ave, New York 
• Contact: www.mollysshebeennyc.com | (212) 889-3361 | info@mollysshebeennyc.com
• Pro Tip: Get the shepherd’s pie. Those fireplace seats are snagged immediately, so be prepared to hover or get lucky.

Black Mountain Wine House

This Boerum Hill spot is basically a log cabin somebody dropped in Brooklyn. It’s the definition of cozy, with a rustic feel and a great fireplace. It’s one of the best low-key date spots.

• Price: $$
• Cuisine: Wine Bar
• Location: 415 Union St Ground Floor, Brooklyn, NY
• Contact: www.blkmtnwinehouse.com | (718) 522-4340 | blackmountainwinehouse@gmail.com
• Pro Tip: It’s tiny. No, like tiny. You’ll be making friends with your neighbors whether you want to or not. Not for a big group.

The Marlton Hotel

Hotel lobbies are the oldest trick in the book for finding a good fireplace. The Marlton’s lobby bar is a classic “if you know, you know” spot in the Village. It’s got an old-world vibe, comfy sofas, and a massive fireplace that’s always going.

• Price: $$$
• Location: 5 W 8th St, New York, NY 10011 (Greenwich Village)
• Contact: www.marltonhotel.com | 212 321 0100 | info@themarlton.com
• Pro Tip: Great for a daytime meeting or a pre-dinner drink. It’s laptop-friendly during the day but flips to a full-on scene at night.

Gramercy Tavern

An icon for a reason. The main dining room is a whole production, but “The Tavern” area in the front is more casual and has a huge wood-burning fireplace. It’s one of the best restaurant bars in the city, period.

• Price: $$$ – $$$$
• Cuisine: American 
• Location: 42 E 20th St, New York
• Contact: https://www.gramercytavern.com | 1 212-477-0777
• Pro Tip: The Tavern is walk-in only. Put your name down and be prepared to wait at the bar. It’s worth it.

The Winslow

This East Village gin bar has a cozy fireplace nook in the back that’s a lifesaver on a cold night. It’s lively but not obnoxious, and they take their gin seriously.

• Price: $$
• Cuisine: British Pub 
• Location: 243 E 14th St, New York
• Contact: https://thewinslownyc.com | 212-777-7717 | Info@thewinslownyc.com
• Pro Tip: They have a literal “Gin-O-Pedia” menu. If you’re overwhelmed, just tell the bartender what you like, and they’ll sort you out.

The Landmark Tavern

One of the oldest bars in the city, this Hell’s Kitchen spot has seen it all. It’s a classic Irish pub with an original potbelly stove and a real fireplace. Feels like stepping back in time.

• Price: $$
• Cuisine: Irish Pub
• Location: 626 11th Ave, New York
• Contact: https://thelandmarktavern.com | (212)-247-2562 | info@thelandmarktavern.com
• Pro Tip: It’s way over on the west side, so it’s a perfect escape if you’re at the Javits Center or just want to feel worlds away from Midtown.

The Campbell

Want to feel like an old-school robber baron? Go to The Campbell. It’s literally an old office inside Grand Central. The space is nuts—25-foot ceilings, stained-glass, and a fireplace you could walk into.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine: Cocktail Bar
• Location: 15 Vanderbilt Ave, New York
• Contact: https://www.thecampbellnyc.com | (917) 209-3440
• Pro Tip: There’s a dress code. Don’t roll in with your sneakers and a backpack. This is where you take someone you want to impress, right off the train.

Art Bar

A real West Village survivor. The front is just a long, narrow bar, but you’re here for the back room. It’s a dark, lounge-y space with velvet couches, weird art, and the fireplace.

• Price: $$
• Cuisine: Bar, American Pub
• Location: 52 8th Ave, New York
• Contact: www.artbar.com | (212) 727-0244
• Pro Tip: The back room is perfect for a group. It feels like you’re hanging out in your coolest friend’s basement from the 90s.

The Penrose

This UES gastropub is always bustling. The fireplace is in a slightly-less-hectic side room, offering a cozy retreat from the main bar scene. Solid cocktails and food.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine: Gastropub, American
• Location: 1590 2nd Ave 2nd floor, New York
• Contact: www.penrosebar.com | (212) 203-2751 | info@penrosebar.com
• Pro Tip: It gets loud, so don’t come here for a quiet heart-to-heart. But if you want a lively vibe with a side of fireplace, it’s a go.

Union Hall

This place is huge. It’s a Park Slope staple with bocce courts, a music venue downstairs, and the bar you care about upstairs. It’s like a giant library with two fireplaces, bookshelves, and sofas you can actually sink into.

• Price: $$
• Cuisine: Bar
• Location: 702 Union St, Brooklyn, NY
• Contact: https://unionhallny.com | (718) 638-4400 | info@unionhallny.com
• Pro Tip: This is one of the few spots where you can bring a group and actually find a seat. Great for catching up.

The Flatiron Room

For a more sophisticated night, this whiskey bar is a top choice. It’s all dark wood, velvet curtains, and live jazz. The fireplace adds to the warm, grown-up atmosphere.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine: American
• Location: 37 W 26th St, New York (other locations)
• Contact: https://theflatironroom.com | (212) 725-3860
• Pro Tip: This is a whiskey lover’s paradise with a “bottle keep” program. Make reservations, especially on jazz nights.

Valerie

Right near Times Square, Valerie is a stunning, Art Deco-inspired gin bar. It’s a surprisingly chic escape from the Midtown madness, with a fireplace that anchors its lounge.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine: American
• Location: 45 W 45th St, New York
• Contact: www.valerienewyorkcity.com | (212) 302-4545
• Pro Tip: A great pre-theater option that doesn’t feel like a tourist trap. Their gin cocktails are the real deal.

Harlem Public

This spot brings a fun, quirky, and cozy vibe to Hamilton Heights. It’s a neighborhood gastropub known for its creative food and cocktails, and its fireplace is a major draw for uptown locals.

• Price: $$
• Cuisine: American
• Location: 3612 Broadway, New York
• Contact: www.harlempublic.com | (212) 939-9404 | info@harlempublic.com
• Pro Tip: Try the “Loco Fries.” The whole vibe is fun and unpretentious.

Donovan’s Pub

If you’re looking for old-school Queens, this is it. Donovan’s in Woodside has been around since 1966 and feels like a time capsule. It’s an authentic Irish-American pub with multiple fireplaces and zero pretension.

• Price: $$
• Cuisine: Irish-American, Pub
• Location: 57-24 Roosevelt Ave, Woodside, NY
• Contact: https://donovansny.com | (718) 429-9339 | info@donovansny.com
• Pro Tip: Famous for its burger, which consistently ranks as one of the best in the entire city. Worth the trip.

Bemelmans Bar

This is an experience. It’s inside The Carlyle, so yes, it’s expensive. You’re paying for the “Madeline” murals, the live piano, and the chance to feel like an Upper East Side character.

• Price: $$$$
• Cuisine: Cocktail Bar
• Location: The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel, 35 E 76th St, New York
• Contact: www.rosewoodhotels.com/en/the-carlyle-new-york/dining/bemelmans-bar | 1 212-570-7120 | bemelmansbar@rosewoodhotels.com
• Pro Tip: There’s a cover for the music, and “smart casual” means “don’t look sloppy.” The fireplace is just one part of the whole ridiculous, timeless package.

Oscar Wilde

If “less is more” isn’t your thing, Oscar Wilde is your bar. The decor is explosively Victorian, with chandeliers, statues, and the longest bar in NYC. It also has multiple fireplaces, so your odds of snagging a warm seat are pretty high.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine: American
• Location: 45 W 27th St, New York  (NoMad)
• Contact: www.oscarwildenyc.com | (212) 213-3066
• Pro Tip: It’s a total scene, especially on weekends. Go during an off-hour if you actually want to take in the wild decor.

Lobby Bar at The Bowery Hotel

If you want the definition of “cozy New York,” this is probably it. The Bowery Hotel lobby is all dim lighting, velvet sofas, old rugs, and a massive wood-burning fireplace. It’s where you go when you want time to slow down.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine: Cocktail Bar, Lounge
• Location: 335 Bowery, New York
• Contact: https://theboweryhotel.com | (212) 505-9100 | reservations@bohonyc.com
• Pro Tip: No reservations, so just walk in. It fills up fast, especially on cold nights. Go early or be prepared to wait.

Fraunces Tavern

This place has been here since 1762. It’s the city’s oldest bar, and yeah, it’s got fireplaces that look like George Washington himself used them. It’s a warm hug from the 18th century, with hearty food and a massive whiskey list.

• Price: $$
• Cuisine: American, Pub
• Location: 54 Pearl St, New York
• Contact: www.frauncestavern.com | (212) 968-1776 | info@frauncestavern.com
• Pro Tip: It’s part-museum, part-bar. The upstairs bar (The Dingle Whiskey Bar) is usually quieter and has the best cozy vibe.

Need a Spot Near Midtown?

Okay, so you’ve warmed up by the fire, but now you have to meet friends for dinner, and they picked… Times Square. Don’t panic. You don’t have to settle for a tourist trap. Before you go, check out our guide to Fancy-ish Restaurants Near Times Square for a Worthwhile Meal to find a spot that’s actually good.