Where to Buy the Best Thanksgiving Pie in NYC (2025 Guide)
While the turkey gets a lot of attention, the pie is the real star of the Thanksgiving table. It is the sweet reward everyone is secretly saving room for. But in a typical New York City apartment, baking a pie from scratch can be a challenge. This is the year to let the pros handle dessert. We have done the research to find where to buy the best Thanksgiving pie in NYC.
We looked at social media and local favorites to find the must-have pies in the city for 2025. From classic pumpkin to modern creations, here is your guide to securing the perfect pie.
Heads up: Holiday menus, prices, and pre-order dates can change. It’s always a smart move to check the official website or social pages for the most current info before you lock in your dessert plans.
The Only Thanksgiving Pie Guide You Need for NYC This Year
The Icons: Can’t-Go-Wrong Classics
Petee’s Pie Company
When you talk about pie in NYC, Petee’s is always part of the conversation. This Lower East Side shop uses high-quality, seasonal ingredients, and their crust is top-notch. For Thanksgiving, you can’t go wrong with their classic Pumpkin, Hudson Valley Apple, or Salty Chocolate Chess.
- Price: $$$
- Location: 61 Delancey St, New York
- Website: https://www.peteespie.com
- Pro Tip: Thanksgiving pre-orders are a must as they sell out very fast. Watch their website in October for the holiday menu to go live.
Bubby’s
Bubby’s is known for its homestyle American comfort food, and their pies are a big part of that. Made from scratch with simple ingredients, these pies taste very traditional. Their Mile-High Apple Pie is a showstopper.
- Price: $$$
- Location: 120 Hudson St, New York
- Website: https://www.bubbys.com
- Pro Tip: You can order pies on their own or as part of a full Thanksgiving takeout meal. Pre-order well in advance.
Four & Twenty Blackbirds
This Brooklyn pie shop is known for its creative and well-made pies. They are famous for their Salty Honey and Salted Caramel Apple pies, which have a large following. Their Thanksgiving menu always features unique flavor combinations.
- Price: $$$
- Location: 439 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
- Website: https://www.birdsblack.com
- Pro Tip: Sign up for their newsletter to be the first to know when their organized pre-order system goes live.
Little Pie Company
This spot in the Theater District has been a local favorite for years. Little Pie Company is famous for its Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie, which is a very popular choice. Their pies taste fresh and homemade.
- Price: $$$
- Location: 424 W 43rd St, New York
- Website: https://www.littlepiecompany.com
- Pro Tip: They ship nationwide, so you can send a pie to family who can’t make it to NYC.
Popular Spots & Neighborhood Favorites
Martha’s Country Bakery
A true NYC favorite, Martha’s is known for its huge display cases filled with cakes and pies. For Thanksgiving, their classic Pumpkin, Apple Crumb, and Cherry pies are always a hit. The portions are generous.
- Price: $$
- Location: Multiple locations in Brooklyn & Queens
- Website: https://www.marthascountrybakery.com/
- Pro Tip: They take pre-orders, but their locations are also good for a last-minute pickup if you are willing to wait in line.
Daily Provisions
From the same team as Gramercy Tavern, Daily Provisions is a go-to for high-quality food. Their seasonal pies are always a great choice, featuring classic flavors like Pumpkin and Apple Crumb made with excellent ingredients.
- Price: $$$
- Location: Multiple locations throughout NYC
- Website: https://www.dailyprovisionsnyc.com
- Pro Tip: This is a great spot to pick up both pies and gourmet side dishes. Pre-ordering is essential for holiday items.
Partybus Bakeshop
This Lower East Side bakery has a serious following for its breads and pastries. For Thanksgiving, they offer a great menu of pies that are both rustic and refined. Their crust is known for being unbelievably flaky.
- Price: $$$
- Location: 31 Essex St, New York, NY 10002
- Website: https://www.partybusbakeshop.com
- Pro Tip: Watch their Instagram for the official Thanksgiving menu. Pre-ordering is the only way to guarantee you will get a pie.
Breads Bakery
While picking up their famous chocolate babka, you can also grab their holiday pies. Breads Bakery offers a great lineup for Thanksgiving, including a rustic apple galette and a creamy pumpkin pie.
- Price: $$$
- Location: Multiple locations, including near Union Square.
- Website: https://www.breadsbakery.com
- Pro Tip: This is a perfect one-stop-shop for your Thanksgiving carbs: dinner rolls, babka for breakfast, and a pie for dessert.
Maman
This French-inspired cafe is known for its great baked goods. For Thanksgiving, Maman usually offers rustic-style pies and tarts. Their Brown Butter Pecan Pie is a standout.
- Price: $$$
- Location: Multiple locations throughout NYC.
- Website: https://mamannyc.com
- Pro Tip: Their pies have a great presentation and are a perfect contribution to a potluck. Pre-order online.
Magnolia Bakery
They are famous for banana pudding, but their pies are a solid choice for a traditional Thanksgiving. Their Apple Crumb Pie is a classic, and you can often find seasonal specials.
- Price: $$$
- Location: Multiple locations, including Bleecker St.
- Website: https://www.magnoliabakery.com
- Pro Tip: A reliable option that you can find all over the city, and they often offer delivery.
Abu’s Homestyle Bakery
For a unique NYC pie, try the Navy Bean Pie from Abu’s in Brooklyn. The texture is similar to a pumpkin pie but with its own distinct flavor. It will be a conversation starter at your dinner.
- Price: $$
- Location: 1184 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11216
- Website: https://abusbeanpie.com
- Pro Tip: This is a neighborhood institution, so be prepared for a line. Call ahead to check holiday hours.
The Good Batch
This Clinton Hill bakery is known for its cookies, but their pies are a hidden treat. For the holidays, they offer classic pies like Double Crusted Apple and Brown Butter Pumpkin.
- Price: $$$
- Location: 936 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11238
- Website: https://thegoodbatch.com
- Pro Tip: Their Thanksgiving pre-order menu also includes breakfast items, which can save you from cooking the next morning.
For Every Dietary Need
Erin McKenna’s Bakery
This is a top spot for anyone with dietary restrictions, as the bakery is dedicated vegan AND gluten-free. They offer Pumpkin and Apple pies that are so good, you would never know what is “missing.”
- Price: $$$
- Location: 248 Broome St, New York, NY 10002
- Website: https://www.erinmckennasbakery.com
- Pro Tip: A must if you have guests with allergies. Pre-ordering for Thanksgiving is essential due to high demand.
By the Way Bakery
Another great option for gluten-free and dairy-free treats. By the Way Bakery makes well-made baked goods that are allergy-friendly. Their Thanksgiving pie selection is always classic.
- Price: $$$
- Location: Multiple locations in Manhattan and Brooklyn.
- Website: https://www.btwbakery.com
- Pro Tip: Their baked goods are also certified kosher, making them an inclusive option for any holiday gathering.
Peacefood Cafe
A popular vegan kitchen, Peacefood is a go-to for plant-based comfort food, and their desserts are no exception. They usually offer vegan Pumpkin and Apple Pies for the holidays.
- Price: $$$
- Location: Multiple locations in Manhattan.
- Website: https://www.peacefoodcafe.com
- Pro Tip: You can also order some of their savory sides to round out your vegan-friendly Thanksgiving offerings.
Don’t Want to Host at All?
If even picking up a pie sounds like too much work, you can let a restaurant handle the entire feast. For a full list of great spots ready to host you for a stress-free holiday meal, check out our guide 20+ Best Restaurants for a Stress-Free Thanksgiving Dinner in NYC (2025).
More…