Halloween Costumes NYC: 15+ Best Stores to Shop Now
If you’re still scrolling through Amazon, wondering if that $20 costume will actually arrive before Halloween—pause. NYC is packed with real-deal spots where you can find everything from spine-chilling masks to runway-level glam. Whether you’re planning to be a disco diva, a rock god, or a literal demon in pleather, here’s your survival guide to the best Halloween stores for costumes in NYC. Let’s get spooky (and maybe a little fabulous).
Store hours, pop-up spots, and stock can change fast. Always check the official website or call ahead before you go.
15+ Best Halloween Stores for Costumes in NYC
Abracadabra Superstore
This Midtown Halloween store makes you feel like you’ve accidentally walked into a movie set. From movie-quality masks to prosthetic fangs and everything in between, it’s a treasure chest for costume perfectionists.
- Price: $$
- Location: 19 W 21st St, New York
- Contact: https://abracadabranyc.com | 212-627-5194
- Best For: High-quality costumes and pro-level makeup.
Gothic Renaissance NYC
Need something darker? This East Village store offers Halloween items like corsets, masks, velvet cloaks, and platform boots. It’s queer-owned, safe, and dripping with character.
- Price: $$$
- Location: 110 4th Ave, New York
- Contact: https://gothrenyc.com | 212-780-9558
- Best For: Vampires, goths, and dramatic devils.
Screaming Mimis Vintage
If you’d rather channel disco fever than the undead, this vintage shop has racks full of retro gems. The costumes are perfect for decade-themed parties, music festivals, or Halloween looks that scream originality.
- Price: $$$
- Location: 240 W 14th St, New York
- Contact: https://www.screamingmimis.com | 212-677-6464
- Best For: Costumes inspired by the fashion of past decades.
Village Party Store
This one’s your one-stop shop if your Halloween plans include balloons, props, or throwing a full-blown bash. And don’t blame the store if you walk out with a pink goblet that says Sexy Witch.
- Price: $$
- Location: 13 E 8th St, New York
- Contact: https://partystorenewyork.net | 212-675-9697
- Best For: Party planners and anyone going all out on decorations.
Brooklyn Superhero Supply Company
Why be Batman when you can be you, but with a cape? Design your costume from scratch with emblems, belts, and colorful capes, then stock up on “Truth Serum”.
- Price: $-$$
- Location: 372 5th Ave, Brooklyn
- Contact: https://www.superherosupplies.com
- Best For: Creative kids and adults.
Trash and Vaudeville
This iconic punk rock shop has been around since the 1970s and continues to deliver. If your costume involves leather pants, studded belts, or rock-star rebellion, you’ll feel right at home.
- Price: $$
- Location: 96 E 7th St, New York
- Contact: https://www.trashandvaudeville.com | 212-777-1727
- Best For: Edgy looks and rock-inspired fits.
Spark Pretty
If Halloween means ‘80s, ‘90s, and early 2000s glam to you, you’ll love shopping at Spark Pretty. This East Village gem is packed with neon, sequins, and vintage fabulousness.
- Price: $$
- Location: 333 E 9th St, New York
- Contact: https://shop.sparkpretty.com | 646- 850-0327 | contact@sparkpretty.com
- Best For: Glam looks and statement makers.
Spirit Halloween
You know it’s officially a spooky season when Spirit starts haunting empty storefronts. It’s the ultimate crowd-pleaser, with costumes for all ages, home décor, and the occasional terrifying animatronic that you’ll regret standing too close to.
- Price: $$
- Location: 510 6th Avenue, New York (other locations)
- Contact: https://stores.spirithalloween.com
- Best For: Classic costumes and easy one-stop shopping.
Frank Bee Costume Center
A Bronx legend that’s been around for over 50 years, Frank Bee has thousands of costumes in stock year-round. Going for scary, silly, or show-stopping? This family-run shop’s got it all.
- Price: $$
- Location: 3435 E Tremont Ave, Bronx
- Contact: https://www.facebook.com/FrankBeeCostume
- Best For: Tried-and-true costume staples for every age.
Halloween Adventure
A two-floor Halloween store in the East Village that’s practically an institution. With its massive selection of wigs, masks, and props, it’s where theatre kids and partygoers unite.
- Price: $$
- Location: 104 4th Ave, New York
- Contact: https://www.nychalloweenadventure.com | 212-673-4546 | HalloweenAdventureNYC@gmail.com
- Best For: Theatrical types.
Patricia Field
If your Halloween look needs to serve fashion fantasy, this is your spot. Expect eccentric, glam, and one-of-a-kind pieces that will make your costume look like couture.
- Price: $$-$$$
- Location: 211 E Broadway, New York
- Contact: https://patriciafield.com | 212-966-4066
- Best For: Fashionistas.
Costume Closet
Hidden in Bushwick, this boutique-style gem is more curated fashion fantasy than costume shop. Rent or buy, but book early—it fills up fast once spooky season hits.
- Price: $-$$
- Location: 83 Starr St, Brooklyn
- Contact: https://www.costumeclosetnyc.com
- Best For: Those who want curated, stylist-approved costumes.
Beyond Costumes
A quick trip outside the city, but so worth it. This massive warehouse has thousands of rental costumes, from Shakespeare to sci-fi, and they even tailor looks to fit perfectly.
- Price: $$-$$$
- Location: 145 Saw Mill River Rd FL 3 Ste 31, Yonkers
- Contact: https://www.beyondcostumes.com | 914-963-1333
- Best For: Theater-level costumes.
Party City
Your reliable go-to for quick, affordable costumes and decorations. Their pop-up near Union Square has everything from trendy looks to classic favorites, perfect for last-minute planners.
- Price: $$
- Location: 1 Union Square W, New York
- Contact: https://stores.partycity.com
- Best For: Anyone needing a complete costume in one trip.
The Feather Place
Need some extra flair? This shop specializes in feather boas, angel wings, and accessories that instantly elevate any look. It’s your secret weapon for turning basic into breathtaking.
- Price: $$-$$$
- Location: 40 W 38th St 3rd floor, New York
- Contact: https://featherplace.com | 212-921-4452
- Best For: DIY lovers and dramatic entrances.
House of Holiday
If Halloween Town were real, this would be it. With thousands of costumes, spooky décor, and themed displays, House of Holiday is a destination, not just a store. Even pets get their moment here.
- Price: $$-$$$
- Location: 90-02 Atlantic Ave, Ozone Park
- Contact: https://houseofholiday.com | 833-353-4357 | help@houseofholiday.com
- Best For: Full-family costumes and immersive shopping experiences.
Once you’ve got your costume sorted…
You’ll need somewhere spooky to show it off. Check out 20+ Spookiest Halloween Bars in NYC (2025) for the best places to strut your spooky style, from haunted speakeasies to gothic cocktail lounges.
More…