Best Pizza in Brooklyn: Top-Ranked Pizzerias Loved by Locals
Listen, people get into actual screaming matches over this stuff. I’ve seen friendships strained and dates go silent because someone suggested the “wrong” slice shop. Because Brooklyn pizza New York isn’t just lunch. It is a religion. And we take our worship seriously.
I’ve burned the roof of my mouth more times than I care to admit. But I did it for you.
Maybe you’re doom-scrolling, looking for the best pizza in Brooklyn New York Reddit threads to tell you where to go. Or maybe you’re just standing on a street corner frantically Googling best Brooklyn Pizza near me while your stomach growls. Stop. I’ve got the inside track. From the coal-fired legends to the new-school sourdough wizards, this is where the locals actually eat.
Here is the list that cuts through the noise.
Best Pizza in Brooklyn: Local Favorites and Must-Try Pizzerias
Juliana’s
Founded by pizza legend Patsy Grimaldi, Juliana’s carries on a Brooklyn tradition with its coal-fired pies. Expect a thin, crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and a taste that keeps people coming back.
- Location: 19 Old Fulton St, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 718-596-6700
- Price: $$
Grimaldi’s Pizzeria
With over a century of pizza-making expertise, Grimaldi’s is famous for its brick-oven pies, house-made mozzarella, and secret sauce. The fresh dough, made daily, strikes the perfect balance of chew and crunch.
- Location: 1 Front St, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 718-858-4300
- Price: $$
Sottocasa
This cozy spot specializes in Neapolitan-style pizza baked in a traditional wood-fired oven. Owner Luca trained under master pizzaiolos, so every bite delivers authentic Italian flavors.
- Website: https://brooklyn.sottocasanyc.com Â
- Location: 298 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 718-852-8758
- Price: $-$$
Best Pizza
A Williamsburg favorite, Best Pizza is known for its wood-fired pies with the perfect balance of crispy and chewy crust. Founded by Frank Pinello in 2010, this shop keeps things simple with high-quality ingredients and classic flavors.
- Location: 33 Havemeyer St, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 718-599-2210
- Price: $$
Little Pizza Parlor
A no-fuss neighborhood spot in Downtown Brooklyn, Little Pizza Parlor focuses on fresh ingredients and simple, delicious pies.
- Location: 192 Duffield St, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 347-799-1249
- Price: $$
Ace’s Pizza
Bringing Detroit-style pizza to Brooklyn, Ace’s serves thick, square slices with crispy cheese edges. Their Grandma pizza is another fan favorite.
- Location: 637 Driggs Ave, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 718-764-8200
- Price: $-$$
Vinnie’s Pizzeria
Famous for its creative slices, Vinnie’s keeps things fun with a constantly changing menu. Expect unique toppings, fresh ingredients, and a laid-back ambiance.
- Location: 148 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 718-782-7078
- Price: $-$$
L’Industrie Pizzeria
Blending traditional Italian techniques with New York flavors, L’Industrie is a must-visit. Their thin, crispy crust and fresh toppings make it a favorite among pizza lovers.
- Location: 254 S 2nd St, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 718-599-0002
- Price: $-$$
Dellarocco’s Brick Oven Pizza
This Brooklyn Heights spot serves wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas in an open kitchen, where customers can watch their pizzas bake in the bright red oven.
- Location: 214 Hicks St, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 718-858-1010
- Price: $$
La Villa Pizzeria
Italian classics fill the menu at La Villa Pizzeria, from pizzas and pasta to other traditional dishes. A focus on fresh ingredients and long-standing recipes keeps this spot busy.  Â
- Location: 261 5th Ave, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 718-499-9888
- Price: $$
Lucali
One of Brooklyn’s most famous pizzerias, Lucali is known for long waits and no reservations. The handmade pies and calzones focus on fresh ingredients and careful preparation.
- Location: 575 Henry St, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 718-858-4086
- Price: $$
Ops
Sourdough pizza baked in a wood-fired oven gives this Bushwick spot a distinct style. The naturally leavened crust offers a different texture and flavor compared to traditional New York slices.Â
- Location: 346 Himrod St, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 718-386-4009
- Price: $$
Di Fara Pizza
Handmade pies topped with fresh basil and a drizzle of olive oil keep this family-run shop on every pizza lover’s must-try list. Decades of experience go into every pizza that comes out of the oven.Â
- Location: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 718-258-1367
- Price: $-$$
Table 87
Coal-oven slices used to be impossible to find, but that changed with this shop. Now customers can get a single slice without having to order a full pie, a move that helped Table 87 expand to multiple locations in Brooklyn.Â
- Location: 87 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 718-797-9300
- Price: $$
Giuseppina’s
Brick-oven pizzas, fresh salads, and calzones keep customers coming back at this pizza spot in Brooklyn. The menu stays simple, letting quality ingredients take the lead. Â
- Location: 691 6th Ave, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 718-499-5052
- Price: $$
Union Street Pizza
Creative slices, vegan options, and wings make this spot stand out near Union Street station. A great choice for a quick bite.  Â
- Location: 226 4th Ave, Brooklyn
- Phone: 1 347-916-1121
- Price: $$
Related Reads:
