21+ Unique Winter Date Ideas in NYC (No Skating!)
Skating at Rockefeller Center is for tourists. If you actually live here, you need real winter date ideas. You want things that do not involve massive crowds and rental skates. This city has endless options if you know where to look. These are the places New Yorkers actually go to stay warm and have fun.
A quick heads-up: This is New York. Hours, prices, and dates change constantly. You must always check the official websites before you head out.
Out-of-the-Box Date Ideas NYC Locals Love
1. Warm Up at AIRE Ancient Baths
This is not a casual date. This is a splurge. It is a subterranean spa in Tribeca, all candlelight and thermal baths. It is quiet, incredibly romantic, and the warmest you will feel all winter.
- Price: $$$$
- Location: 88 Franklin St, New York
- Experience Tip: You must book this weeks or even months in advance. It is one of the most famous unique dates in the city. You cannot just walk in.
2. Take the Ferry to QC NY Spa
If you want a spa with a killer view, this is it. You take a quick ferry to Governors Island. QC NY has heated outdoor pools that look directly at the skyline. It feels like an escape, but you never left the city.
- Price: $$$$
- Location: 112 Andes Rd, Governors Island
- Experience Tip: The ferry ride is part of the date. They give you a robe for the whole time. You can easily spend a full day here exploring the themed saunas and relaxation rooms.
3. See a Show at the Comedy Cellar
This is a classic for a reason. You huddle in this tiny basement. You never know if a huge name like Chris Rock or Amy Schumer is going to drop in. It is a perfect, essential New York experience.
- Price: $$ (plus a two-item minimum)
- Location: 117 MacDougal St, New York
- Experience Tip: Make reservations the second they become available (usually one week out). They sell out instantly. Also, prepare to sit very, very close to your neighbors.
4. Have Dinner and a Movie at Nitehawk
This is not your local multiplex. Nitehawk Cinema serves real food and strong cocktails right to your seat. They show new releases and cool indie films.
- Price: $$
- Location: 136 Metropolitan Ave (Williamsburg) | 188 Prospect Park West (Prospect Park)
- Experience Tip: You should arrive 30 minutes early. This lets you look at the menu and put in your main order before the lights go down. You write your order on a piece of paper.
5. Walk Through a Digital Universe at Arte Museum
This is a new, massive immersive art museum in Chelsea. It uses light, sound, and even scent to make you feel like you are inside nature. It is visually spectacular.
- Price: $$$
- Location: 41 W 25th St, New York
- Experience Tip: The ‘STAR’ room and the ‘WAVE’ exhibit are the two you cannot miss. They are built for photos.
6. Immerse Yourself in Digital Art at ARTECHOUSE
This is the original high-tech art spot in the city, located in the boiler room under Chelsea Market. They use cutting-edge, large-scale projections and interactive technology to create stunning digital worlds. The exhibits rotate, so it’s almost always something new.
- Price: $$$
- Location: 439 W 15th St, Chelsea
- Pro Tip: This is right inside Chelsea Market. Plan to grab drinks or food in the market before or after your time slot. Make sure to check what exhibit is currently running, as they change every few months.
7. Take a Cooking Class Together
Instead of just going to dinner, you can learn to make it. Places like Taste Buds Kitchen or the Institute of Culinary Education have one-night classes for couples. You can learn anything from pasta-making to pastries.
- Price: $$$
- Location: Varies
- Experience Tip: You get to eat what you make, so you should come hungry. It is a great way to see how you work together as a team.
8. Play Indoor Mini-Golf at Swingers
This is not your childhood mini-golf. Swingers is a two-story, indoor “crazy golf” spot. It features craft cocktails, street food vendors, and live DJs. It is a whole party.
- Price: $$$
- Location: 35 W 29th St, New York
- Experience Tip: You must book a time slot online. This place gets very crowded, especially on weekends.
9. Get Your Hands Dirty at a Pottery Class
Do you remember that scene from Ghost? Now you can try it. Sign up for a one-off pottery class at a studio like Choplet in Brooklyn or Pottery Studio 1 in Manhattan. It is fun, messy, and you get a (possibly weird-looking) souvenir.
- Price: $$
- Location: Varies
- Experience Tip: Do not wear your best clothes. You will get clay on you. That is the point.
10. Try Axe Throwing
Nothing says “I love you” like throwing a sharp piece of metal at a wooden target. Spots like Kick Axe Throwing in Brooklyn are surprisingly fun. It is a great way to blow off steam.
- Price: $$
- Location: 622 Degraw St, Brooklyn
- Experience Tip: They have cozy “lumberjack” themed bars. You can grab a drink after you finish throwing.
11. See Some Magic at Speakeasy Magick
Sleep No More is gone, but the magic show that played at its hotel lives on. Speakeasy Magick moved to a new home in the Flatiron District. It is an intimate, close-up magic show with multiple magicians in a moody, old-world bar.
- Price: $$$
- Location: The Overlook Bar, 25 W 24th St, New York
- Experience Tip: This is a perfect replacement for the old McKittrick vibe. You should dress up a little. All guests must be 21 or older.
12. Listen to Live Music at The Jazz Club
If you want a truly fancy, “old New York” night, The Jazz Club at the Aman hotel is it. It is a true speakeasy with incredible live music. It is an absolute splurge, but it is unforgettable.
- Price: $$$$
- Location: 730 5th Ave, New York
- Experience Tip: There is a strict dress code. This is your chance to look sharp. It is one of the most exclusive, expensive date nights in the city.
13. Have a Date Night at The Met
On Friday and Saturday nights, The Met stays open late. It is way less crowded. They have live music in the Balcony Lounge, and you can grab a drink. What is more romantic than wandering empty art galleries?
- Price: $$ (Pay-what-you-wish for NY residents)
- Location: 1000 5th Ave, New York
- Experience Tip: Head to the European Sculpture Court. It is one of the best spots to sit and chat. Or, visit the Temple of Dendur.
14. Get Cozy at Housing Works Bookstore
This is one of the most beautiful bookstores in the city. You can grab a coffee or a glass of wine from their café, find a comfy chair, and browse for books. All the profits go to charity, which makes it even better.
- Price: $
- Location: 126 Crosby St, New York
- Experience Tip: They often have live events and readings in the evenings. Check their calendar.
15. Try Dining in the Dark
Are you looking for truly out-of-the-box date ideas? This is it. You eat a full meal in a pitch-black restaurant. You must rely only on taste, smell, and sound. It is a weird, fun, and totally unique bonding experience.
- Price: $$$
- Location: Varies (It is an event held at different restaurants)
- Experience Tip: My one practical piece of advice: Do not wear a white shirt. Seriously.
16. Play Shuffleboard at Royal Palms
You can head to Gowanus and step into this massive, tropical-themed shuffleboard club. It feels like being in Florida in the 1970s. They have giant board games, food trucks, and great cocktails.
- Price: $$
- Location: 514 Union St, Brooklyn
- Experience Tip: Courts are first-come, first-served. Put your name down and grab a drink. The wait is part of the fun.
17. Do a Paint and Sip Night
This is a simple, no-pressure date. You follow an instructor to paint a picture while you have a few glasses of wine.
- Price: $$
- Location: Varies (Paint & Sip Studio NY, The Painting Lounge)
- Experience Tip: It does not matter if you are a bad artist. In fact, it is usually funnier if you are.
18. See a Burlesque Show at The Slipper Room
For something a little more risqué, head to the Lower East Side. The Slipper Room has nightly neo-burlesque shows. They are part performance art, part comedy, and always impressive.
- Price: $$
- Location: 167 Orchard St, New York
- Experience Tip: You should buy tickets in advance for a guaranteed seat. The standing-room-only area gets packed.
19. Make Your Own Scent at Olfactory NYC
This is one of the most unique winter date ideas. You go to this studio in SoHo. You learn about different scents. Then, you work with a “scent-tender” to create and bottle your own custom fragrance.
- Price: $$$
- Location: 281 Mott St, New York
- Experience Tip: You will leave with a full bottle of your creation. You can even name it. It is a great souvenir of the date.
20. Escape to the Tropics at Brooklyn Botanic Garden
When it is gray and miserable outside, head to the indoor pavilions at the BBG. The Tropical Pavilion is warm, humid, and full of palm trees. It is the cheapest trip to the tropics you can take.
- Price: $$
- Location: 990 Washington Ave, Brooklyn
- Experience Tip: Check out the Desert Pavilion too. It is a completely different (and very cool) vibe.
21. Go to a Candlelight Concert
These concerts happen in beautiful, historic churches and buildings all over the city. They are lit by thousands of candles. They play everything from classical to Taylor Swift. It is pure romance.
- Price: $$$
- Location: Varies
- Experience Tip: This is a top-tier date. The atmosphere is unbeatable.
22. Play Indoor Lawn Games at The Lawn Club
It is too cold for an actual lawn. So, you go to The Lawn Club in the Seaport. They have indoor “lawns” for games like cornhole, ladder golf, and bocce. You can do all of this while grabbing drinks from the bar.
- Price: $$
- Location: 101 Seaport Blvd, New York
- Experience Tip: This is an excellent spot for a double date or a group hang. It is active, social, and low-pressure.
Thinking About Lacing Up After All?
Are you still thinking about skating? After all that? Fine. We get it. It is a classic for a reason. If you are going to do it, you should do it right. Check out our Ultimate Guide To Ice Skating In NYC (2025): Best Ice Skating Rinks, Prices, & Tips.
More…
