15 Unique Halloween Date Ideas in NYC for a Spooky Night Out
Forget a basic dinner and a movie—it is the season to do something spooky. Halloween in New York City is a great time to plan a date night that is a little more exciting than your usual routine. Whether you and your partner are into genuine scares, themed cocktails, or just the autumn atmosphere, there are many ways to celebrate. If you have been searching for the best Halloween date ideas in NYC this 2025, you are in the right place. We have looked through social media to find the most popular and unique activities that are great for a spooky date night.
Heads up, spooky planners! Event dates, times, and ticket prices for seasonal activities can change. It is always a good idea to check the official websites for the most current 2025 info and to book your tickets in advance before they sell out.
Best Halloween Date Ideas in NYC 2025
For Those Who Love a Good Scare
1. Blood Manor
If your idea of a great date is screaming while clinging to each other, then Blood Manor is your spot. This is NYC’s premier haunted house, a large, terrifying maze of themed rooms and creepy corridors.
- Price: $$$
- Location: 359 Broadway, New York
- Contact: https://www.bloodmanor.com | (212) 290-2825
- Good For: Adrenaline junkies. Lines can get very long, so buy the “RIP Express Entry” tickets online to skip the worst of the queue.
2. A Spooky Trip to Sleepy Hollow
Take a short trip out of the city to where the legend began. In October, Sleepy Hollow has haunted hayrides, cemetery tours, and the main event: The Great Jack O’Lantern Blaze, with thousands of carved, glowing pumpkins.
- Price: $$-$$$$ (Varies by event)
- Location: Sleepy Hollow & Croton-on-Hudson, NY (Accessible via Metro-North)
- Contact: https://visitsleepyhollow.comÂ
- Good For: A full-day adventure. Tickets for the Jack O’Lantern Blaze sell out months in advance, so plan way ahead.
3. New York City Ghost Tour
Explore the city’s haunted history on a walking tour. Companies like Boroughs of the Dead share chilling tales of local legends and historic hauntings in neighborhoods like Greenwich Village.
- Price: $$
- Location: Various starting points, often in Greenwich Village.
- Contact: https://boroughsofthedead.com | (917) 408-7422 | info@boroughsofthedead.com
- Good For: History buffs and paranormal fans. Wear comfortable shoes for walking.
4. Nightmare Gothic: A Victorian Seance
For a unique and immersive horror experience, this is an intimate, interactive seance set in a historic Lower East Side building. It is designed to be genuinely unsettling and psychologically creepy.
- Price: $$$
- Location: 107 Suffolk St, New York
- Contact: https://www.nightmarenyc.com
- Good For: Couples who love psychological horror. This is not for the faint of heart.
- Tickets: Buy here.
For Themed Drinks & Atmosphere
5. Beetle House
This is a Halloween-themed bar that is open year-round but is a must-visit in October. Inspired by Tim Burton, it is a dark, quirky spot where costumed characters often roam the room.
- Price: $$$
- Cuisine: American Themed
- Location: 308 E 6th St, New York
- Contact: https://www.beetlehousenyc.com | info@beetlehousenyc.com | 646-510-4786
- Good For: Tim Burton fans. Reservations are essential, especially in October.
6. Black Lagoon Pop-Up
Keep an eye out for the location of this spooky pop-up bar. Black Lagoon takes over an existing bar for the Halloween season and transforms it into a horror-themed speakeasy with creative, goth-inspired cocktails.
- Price: $$
- Cuisine: Themed Bar
- Location: Location varies annually.
- Contact: https://www.blacklagoonpopup.comÂ
- Good For: A trendy and very photo-worthy experience. Follow their social media to find the 2025 location.
7. Jekyll & Hyde Club
A classic NYC spot where the decorations move and spooky characters interact with you during your meal. It is a campy, theatrical, and fun time if you do not take it too seriously.
- Price: $$
- Cuisine: American
- Location: 91 7th Ave S, New York
- Contact: http://www.jekyllandhydeclub.com | (212) 989-7701
- Good For: A fun, interactive, and less-intense spooky experience.
Creative Activities & Outings
8. Village Halloween Parade
Instead of just watching the parade, be in it. The only requirement to march is that you must be in costume. Creating a couple’s costume and joining the massive procession is a great date experience.
- Price: FREE (to march)
- Location: 6th Avenue between Spring St and 16th St, Manhattan
- Contact: https://halloween-nyc.com | info@halloween-nyc.com
- Good For: Creative couples. If you just want to watch, find a spot along the route hours early as it gets very crowded.
9. A Movie Night at Nitehawk Cinema
Nitehawk is a dine-in movie theater that takes its holiday programming seriously. In October, they always have a schedule packed with classic horror films.
- Price: $$
- Location: Williamsburg & Prospect Park, Brooklyn
- Contact: https://nitehawkcinema.com | (718) 782-8370
- Good For: Film lovers. Book your tickets in advance, as special screenings sell out.
10. Green-Wood Cemetery Tour
In October, the historic Green-Wood Cemetery’s main event is NIGHTFALL, a spectacular two-night experience on October 16th and 17th. As you wander the grounds after dark, you’ll find a mix of mysterious melodies from Death of Classical, circus wonders by Bindlestiff Family Cirkus, and chilling tales from Morbid Anatomy, creating an unforgettable and atmospheric date night.
- Price: $$
- Location: 500 25th St, Brooklyn, NY 11232
- Contact: https://www.green-wood.com | (718) 768-7300
- Good For: A scenic and historical date. The fall foliage here is also some of the best in the city.
11. Candlelight: A Haunted Evening of Halloween Classics
For a more romantic date, listen to a string quartet play chilling themes from classic horror movies, all in a beautiful venue lit by thousands of candles.
- Price: $$-$$$
- Location: Various venues across NYC.
- Contact: https://feverup.com/en/new-york/candlelightÂ
- Good For: A romantic and atmospheric date night in a relaxed setting.
12. The Cauldron
Mix your own boozy “potions” at this magical, wizard-themed bar. You get a robe and a wand and follow instructions to create your own interactive cocktails that bubble and smoke.
- Price: $$$
- Cuisine: Themed Bar
- Location: 47 Stone St, New York
- Contact: https://thecauldron.io/nyc | (917) 635-1969
- Good For: An interactive and playful date. Book the “Potions Experience” online in advance.
For a Halloween Party
13. McKittrick Hotel (Home of “Sleep No More”)
The McKittrick Hotel usually hosts a massive, multi-night Halloween party. It is an immersive, costume-required event that takes over the entire building with live performances and secret rooms to explore.
- Price: $$$$
- Location: 530 W 27th St, New York, NY 10001
- Contact: https://mckittrickhotel.com | (212) 904-1883
- Good For: A big, blowout party experience. The costumes here are next-level, so go all out.
14. House of Yes
This Bushwick club is known for its wild, themed parties, and their Halloween events are famous. Expect incredible performances, great DJs, and some of the most creative costumes anywhere.
- Price: $$-$$$
- Location: 2 Wyckoff Ave, Brooklyn, NY
- Contact: https://houseofyes.orgÂ
- Good For: A high-energy party and dancing. “Costumes are not optional.” They mean it.
15. Webster Hell at Webster Hall
Webster Hall’s annual Halloween party is a massive, multi-floor event. It is a classic NYC nightlife experience with a huge costume contest that has a large cash prize.
- Price: $$$
- Location: 125 E 11th St, New York, NY 10003
- Contact: https://websterhall.com | (212) 353-1600
Looking for a Daytime Fall Activity?
These date ideas are great for a spooky night out. But if you are looking for a classic autumn day trip, a visit to a pumpkin patch is a perfect choice.
For a full list of spots, including some you can get to without a car, check out our guide to the 10+ Best Pumpkin Patches Near NYC (Even Without a Car).
More…