Best Spots to Eat Near Little Italy During the Feast of San Gennaro

Julie Anne L.
· · · · ·

Little Italy during the Feast of San Gennaro is like one big block party that never runs out of food. The streets smell of sausage, peppers, cannoli, and fried dough, and every corner has a line worth standing in. But with so many stalls and restaurants fighting for your attention, it helps to know the best spots to eat near Little Italy during the Feast of San Gennaro. Think of this as your cheat sheet, so you can spend less time wandering and more time eating.

Best Spots to Eat Near Little Italy During the Feast of San Gennaro: Must-Visit Restaurants & Cafés

Da Gennaro

Best spots to eat near Little Italy during the Feast of San Gennar
Photo via @dagennaronyc / Instagram

In the heart of Little Italy, this welcoming spot offers homemade Italian comfort food that’ll remind you of family dinners. With a rustic atmosphere and a menu covering breakfast through dinner, guests can enjoy traditional recipes while celebrating the festivities.

Paesano 

Photo via @markdevincenzo / Instagram

This charming spot, located on Mulberry Street, serves up authentic Italian dishes with recipes that have been passed down through generations. Their extensive menu features everything from pasta and veal to seafood and steaks, offering a cozy atmosphere perfect for any meal during the festival.

La Bella Vita

Just a short walk from Mulberry Street, this gem delivers a delightful menu filled with seafood, meats, and pasta. Their wine selection adds a perfect touch to every dish, making it an ideal spot for a laid-back lunch or dinner during the festival.

Benito One

Best spots to eat near Little Italy during the Feast of San Gennaro
Photo via @jamesandkarla / Instagram

Serving hearty, classic Italian fare in a simple yet welcoming setting, Benito One has been a staple since 1968. It’s known for generous portions and satisfying dishes like veal, eggplant rollatini, and their popular chicken Alfredo.

Caffé Palermo

For dessert, head over to this famous spot that’s been dishing out sweet treats since 1973. Their giant cannoli, tiramisu, and cheesecake are well-loved by locals and visitors alike, making it a must-visit for anyone craving something sweet after a meal in Little Italy.

  • Price: $$
  • Website: www.caffepalermo.com 
  • Location: 148 Mulberry St, New York
  • Phone: 1 212-431-4205

Umbertos Clam House

Best spots to eat near Little Italy during the Feast of San Gennaro
Photo via @umbertos_clamhouse / Instagram

Since 1972, this seafood institution has been serving fresh clams and classic pasta dishes in a no-frills, welcoming environment. Umberto’s is a great spot to escape the crowds and enjoy the freshest seafood around.

Pasquale Jones

Photo via @culinaryagents / Instagram

Known for its wood-fired pizzas and seasonal dishes, Pasquale Jones brings a modern twist to Italian dining. If you’re enjoying their signature clam pie or sipping on an extraordinary wine selection, this spot offers a refined but relaxed dining experience.

Rubirosa

Best spots to eat near Little Italy during the Feast of San Gennaro
Photo via @rubirosa_nyc / Instagram

A favorite for its thin-crust pizzas and fresh pastas, Rubirosa reinvents Italian-American classics. Their tie-dye pizza is a standout, and the cozy space offers a perfect spot to relax after a stroll through the Feast of San Gennaro.

  • Price: $$
  • Website: www.rubirosanyc.com   
  • Location: 235 Mulberry St, New York
  • Phone: 1 212-965-0500

Parm

Best spots to eat near Little Italy during the Feast of San Gennaro
Photo via @parm / Instagram

From the creators of the legendary Carbone restaurant, Parm puts a gourmet spin on Italian-American comfort food. Their iconic chicken parm, homemade meatballs, and rigatoni are prepared with a touch of elegance, guaranteeing a hearty meal experience.

  • Price: $$
  • Cuisine: Italian-American
  • Website: www.parmitalian.com 
  • Location: 248 Mulberry St, New York
  • Phone: 1 212-993-7189

Lombardi’s

Photo via @jamesandkarla / Instagram

As the first pizzeria in the United States, Lombardi’s remains a staple of New York pizza culture. Known for its coal-fired, thin-crust pizza, it’s an essential stop for any pizza lover visiting the neighborhood during the Feast of San Gennaro.

  • Price: $$
  • Website: www.firstpizza.com  
  • Location: 32 Spring St, New York
  • Phone: 1 212-941-7994

Ferrara Bakery & Cafe

An institution since 1892, Ferrara Bakery offers some of the best Italian desserts in the city. Their pastries, including cannoli and tiramisu, are crafted with care—perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth after a day at the festival.

  • Price: $$
  • Website: www.ferraranyc.com   
  • Location: 195 Grand St, New York
  • Phone: 1 212-226-6150

Peasant

Photo via @peasantnyc and @casey.mcquiston / Instagram

Located in NoLiTa, Peasant is a beloved Italian spot known for its wood-fired dishes and handmade pastas. With a focus on seasonal ingredients and traditional cooking methods, it’s the perfect blend of rustic charm and fine dining.

Caffé Roma

Best spots to eat near Little Italy during the Feast of San Gennaro
Photo via @ladoublej / Instagram

Since 1891, Caffé Roma has been perfecting Italian pastries, particularly their hand-rolled, fried cannoli. Located right in the heart of Little Italy, this quaint bakery continues to deliver authentic treats, making it a top choice for anyone craving a sweet finish to their festival experience.

  • Price: $$ 
  • Instagram: @cafferoma.nyc
  • Location: 385 Broome St, New York
  • Phone: 1 212-226-8413

Thai Diner

Best spots to eat near Little Italy during the Feast of San Gennaro
Photo via @thaidiner / Instagram

For something different, this Thai-American diner brings a fun twist to the classic diner experience. Serving up spicy noodles and creative brunch options, it’s a great spot to break away from Italian fare and try something new during the Feast of San Gennaro.

  • Price: $$ 
  • Cuisine: Thai
  • Reservation: Click here.
  • Website: www.thaidiner.com 
  • Location: 186 Mott St, New York

Ceres Pizza

Photo via @ceres.nyc / Instagram

This tiny pizzeria on Mott Street serves up elevated pies with a New York-style sourdough base. Known for its long wait times and high-quality ingredients, Ceres Pizza offers a unique and must-try take on classic pizza that has become a local favorite.

  • Price: $$ 
  • Instagram: @ceres.nyc
  • Location: 164 Mott St, Manhattan, NY

Manero’s of Mulberry

Best spots to eat near Little Italy during the Feast of San Gennaro
Photo via @manerosofmulberry / Instagram

If you’re a fan of NYC-style pizza, Manero’s brings a slice of nostalgia with a Saturday Night Fever twist. Located on Mulberry Street, this family-run pizzeria channels a 1970s vibe, with classic Italian-American dishes and a fun atmosphere. Come for the pizza, stay for the disco-inspired charm.

More…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *