Where to Find the Best Pizza in Each NYC Borough: Top Pizzerias to Try

Julie Anne L.
· · · · ·

When you’re craving a slice of the city’s finest pizza, New York doesn’t disappoint. From crispy crusts to gooey cheese, there’s a pizza for every taste in each of the five boroughs. But if you’re wondering where to find the best pizza in each NYC borough, this guide will lead you straight to the spots that make it easy to pick your favorite. No need to wander around aimlessly — just follow this list for your next pizza adventure.

Where to Find the Best Pizza in Each Borough of NYC

Staten Island

Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern

A true Staten Island institution since 1937, Denino’s is famous for its thin-crust pizza, made fresh daily with family recipes passed down through generations. Located on Richmond Avenue, it’s the spot for classic Italian dishes, including Chicken Parmigiana and Meatballs, alongside some of the best pizza in the borough.

  • Price: $$
  • Instagram: @deninospizza
  • Location: 524 Port Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY
  • Phone: 1 718-442-9401

Joe & Pat’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

Best Pizza in Each NYC Borough
Photo via @joeandpats / Instagram

Established in 1953, Joe & Pat’s is a longstanding family favorite known for its thin-crust pies and authentic Neapolitan recipe. If you’re craving a simple cheese pizza or a hearty pasta dish, this pizzeria offers a taste of tradition and has earned its place in Staten Island’s pizza scene.

  •  Price: $$
  • Website: www.joeandpatsny.com 
  • Location: 1758 Victory Blvd, Staten Island, NY
  • Phone: 1 718-981-0887

Brother’s Pizzeria

Best Pizza in Each NYC Borough
Photo via @brotherspizza_si / Instagram

Serving locals since 1975, Brother’s Pizzeria is renowned for its Sicilian squares and thin-crust pizzas. If you’re grabbing a quick slice or looking to enjoy a full meal, their variety of pies and sandwiches, like the famous Pan Pizza, make it a go-to spot for Staten Island residents.

Bronx

Louie & Ernie’s Pizza

Since 1959, Louie & Ernie’s has been serving traditional thin-crust pies in a cozy, old-school setting. This pizzeria, located in Pelham Bay, continues to draw crowds for its authentic Italian flavors, deliciously crispy crust, and friendly atmosphere.

Full Moon Pizza

Best Pizza in Each NYC Borough
Photo via @mezzalunapizzabronxny / Instagram

Nestled near the heart of Arthur Avenue, Full Moon Pizza has become a favorite late-night spot for pizza lovers. Known for its classic New York-style pizza with a perfect balance of crispy crust and rich sauce, it’s the ideal place to grab a bite after a stroll through the Bronx’s Little Italy.

  • Price: $$
  • Website: www.fullmoonpizza.com 
  • Location: 600 East 187th Street, Bronx, NY
  • Phone: 1 718-584-3451

Zero Otto Nove

Best Pizza in Each NYC Borough
Photo via @bobspizzatour / Instagram

If you’re looking for something a little different, Zero Otto Nove in the Bronx is a must-try. This spot serves pizzas in the Sorrento style, with a puffy yet crispy crust, fresh mozzarella, and unique toppings like butternut squash puree and spicy pancetta. It’s a perfect blend of traditional and innovative pizza-making.

Queens

Milkflower

Best Pizza in Each NYC Borough
Photo via @milkflowernyc / Instagram

For pizza lovers in Astoria, Milkflower is the place to go. This wood-fired pizzeria serves gourmet pies with top-quality ingredients and pairs them with an excellent selection of craft beers. The rustic, hip vibe makes it a great spot to enjoy a meal with friends.

  • Price: $$
  • Website: www.milkflowernyc.com 
  • Location: 34-12 31st Ave, Astoria, NY
  • Phone: 1 718-204-1300

Louie’s

Best Pizza in Each NYC Borough
Photo via @itspizzanite / Instagram

Louie’s in Elmhurst, Queens, offers simple, classic Italian-American comfort food, including its beloved Grandma slice. With a commitment to homemade pasta and pizza made from family recipes, this family-owned gem feels like home, whether you’re dining in or picking up for

  • Price: $$
  • Instagram: @louiespizza
  • Location: 81-34 Baxter Ave #1, Elmhurst, NY
  • Phone: 1 718-440-9346

Amore Pizza

Best Pizza in Each NYC Borough
Photo via @alexandermjuan / Instagram

In Flushing, Amore Pizza is known for its perfectly thin slices and generous cheese toppings. Although it’s cash-only, the service is fast and friendly, and their house special is a must-try for anyone looking to enjoy authentic, flavorful pizza in a relaxed atmosphere.

 Rizzo’s Pizza

Photo via @steinwaystreet / Instagram

Located in Astoria, Rizzo’s serves both round and Sicilian-style pizzas, each with a light, thin crust and big bursts of tomato flavor. With over 20 specialty pies to choose from, you’ll find something that satisfies every pizza craving, if  it’s a classic cheese or a more adventurous topping.

Brooklyn

Di Fara Pizza

Photo via @difaranyc / Instagram

Di Fara Pizza in Midwood is often hailed as one of the best pizzerias in New York City. Famous for its use of premium ingredients like bufala mozzarella and hand-cut pepperoni, this no-frills spot has built a loyal following over the decades. The flavor-packed slices are a must-try for any pizza aficionado.

  • Price: $$
  • Website: www.difarapizzany.com 
  • Location: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY
  • Phone: 1 718-258-1367

Lucali

Best Pizza in Each NYC Borough
Photo via @makinmecaprese / Instagram

In Carroll Gardens, Lucali has earned its reputation for upscale, thin-crust pizzas made with high-quality toppings and cooked in a wood-burning oven. The ambiance is cozy, the menu is simple, and the pizzas are some of the best you’ll find in Brooklyn.

L&B Spumoni Gardens

Photo via @lbspumonigardens / Instagram

L&B Spumoni Gardens, a Brooklyn landmark since 1939, is famous for its thick, cheesy Sicilian pizza served alongside delicious spumoni. If you’re grabbing a slice on a hot summer day or enjoying a full meal with family, this spot remains a staple for pizza lovers in the borough.

Manhattan

John’s of Bleecker Street

A historic pizzeria in Greenwich Village, John’s of Bleecker Street, serves up quintessential New York coal-fired pizza. Since 1929, its crispy, slightly charred crust and fresh toppings have made it one of the most iconic pizzerias in Manhattan.

Rubirosa

Photo via @rubirosa_nyc / Instagram

Located in the heart of Manhattan, Rubirosa offers a unique twist on classic Italian-American pizza. Known for its thin-crust pies, including the signature Tie Dye pizza, it’s a go-to spot for pizza lovers looking for something new while still sticking to traditional flavors.

Joe’s Pizza Broadway

Photo via @sweet_amei / Instagram

If you’re craving a classic New York-style slice, Joe’s Pizza on Broadway is the place to go. Famous for its thin, crisp crust and flavorful sauce, Joe’s Pizza has been serving Manhattan residents and visitors since 1975, making it a must-visit for any pizza enthusiast.

  • Price: $ – $$
  • Instagram: @joespizzanyc
  • Location: 1435 Broadway, New York
  • Phone: 1 646-559-4878

Each borough in New York City brings its twist on pizza, from the crispy, thin crusts of Staten Island to the hearty Sicilian pies of Brooklyn. No matter where you are, there’s always a pizzeria nearby serving up a slice of New York’s best.

More…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *