Best Halloween-Themed Bar & Restaurants to Dine in NYC (2025)

Just because the calendar flips to November 1st, it does not mean the spooky season has to be over. The costumes might be packed away, but the desire for a fun, themed night out is still very real. Luckily, New York City has a great selection of spots where the atmosphere is mysterious all year long. For those looking for the best Halloween-themed bar and restaurants to dine in NYC, this guide is for you.

We have found the year-round haunts and moody spots where you can keep the spirit alive long after the last jack-o’-lantern has flickered out.

A quick heads-up: While these spots are open year-round, it’s always a good idea to check their official websites or social media for the most current hours and reservation policies.

NYC’s Best Halloween-Themed Restaurants to Visit in Nov

Directly Themed Restaurants & Bars

Beetle House

If you are a fan of Tim Burton, this is your year-round destination. Beetle House is an immersive restaurant and bar where it is Halloween every day, with decor inspired by movies like Beetlejuice and The Nightmare Before Christmas.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine: Themed American
• Location: 308 E 6th St, New York
• Contact: https://www.beetlehousenyc.com 
• Pro Tip: This place is very popular. Reservations are a must, especially on a weekend.

Jekyll & Hyde Club

A classic NYC spot for campy, spooky fun. The Jekyll & Hyde Club is more about theatrical entertainment than genuine scares, with talking walls and roaming characters who interact with you.

• Price: $$
• Cuisine: American
• Location: 91 7th Ave S, New York
• Contact: http://www.jekyllandhydeclub.com | (212) 989-7701
• Pro Tip: This is a great spot for groups. The more people you have, the more fun the interactions with the live actors become.

The Cauldron

For a magical and interactive night out, The Cauldron lets you wear a robe, use a magic wand, and mix your own bubbling and smoking “potions” (cocktails). It captures a whimsical, witchy feeling.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine: Themed Bar / Gastropub
• Location: 47 Stone St, New York
• Contact: https://thecauldron.io/nyc | (917) 635-1969
• Pro Tip: You need to book the “Potions Experience” online in advance, as it is a structured, timed activity.

Trailer Park Lounge

For a different kind of theme that is kitschy and quirky, the Trailer Park Lounge is a classic. It is decked out in retro Americana that feels like the set of a campy B-horror movie.

• Price: $$
• Cuisine: American / Bar Food
• Location: 271 W 23rd St, New York
• Contact: http://trailerparklounge.com | 917 261 2777 | lucky0831@mac.com
• Pro Tip: The huge amount of kitschy decor provides endless conversation starters.

Atmospheric & Moody Spots

Lillie’s Victorian Establishment

While not explicitly a Halloween spot, Lillie’s feels like you have stepped into a grand, old Victorian mansion with its ornate, antique decor, creating a perfectly moody setting.

• Price: $$
• Cuisine: American / Gastropub
• Location: 249 W 49th St (Times Square) & 13 E 17th St (Union Square), New York
• Contact: https://www.lilliesnyc.com | (212) 957-4530
• Pro Tip: The Times Square location is particularly grand and is a great pre-theater spot.

Oscar Wilde NYC

Similar to Lillie’s, Oscar Wilde is an ornate Victorian-style bar. With the longest bar in NYC and lavish decor, it feels like a glamorous, old-world mansion.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine: Gastropub
• Location: 45 W 27th St, New York
• Contact: https://www.oscarwildenyc.com | (212) 213-3066 
• Pro Tip: It gets very busy and loud in the evenings, making it great for a high-energy night out.

Black Cat LES

This spot in the Lower East Side captures a witchy, gothic coffee shop feel. It is a dimly lit cafe with a subtle occult theme, great for a low-key date and a deep conversation.

• Price: $
• Cuisine: Coffee Shop / Cafe
• Location: 172 Rivington St, New York
• Contact: https://www.blackcatles.com | +1 646-918-7711 | coffee@blackcatles.com
• Pro Tip: It is small and popular with locals. Try going on a weekday afternoon to get a table.

The Dead Rabbit

This acclaimed Irish bar has a dark, old-world feel that is perfectly atmospheric for November. With sawdust-covered floors and an incredible cocktail program, it evokes a sense of historical mystery.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine: Irish Pub / Cocktails
• Location: 30 Water St, New York
• Contact: https://www.deadrabbitnyc.com | (646) 422-7906 | info@deadrabbitnyc.com
• Pro Tip: Head upstairs for their renowned cocktail parlor, or stay downstairs for a more traditional pub experience.

The McKittrick Hotel (and Gallow Green/The Lodge)

While home to the immersive show “Sleep No More,” the hotel itself has a permanent gothic feel. You can visit its rooftop bar, Gallow Green (seasonal), or the winter-themed Lodge for drinks.

• Price: $$$$
• Cuisine: American
• Location: 530 W 27th St, New York
• Contact: https://mckittrickhotel.com | (212) 904-1883
• Pro Tip: Even if you don’t see the show, visiting the hotel’s bars is an experience. Check their seasonal hours.

Burp Castle

For beer lovers, Burp Castle is a unique spot with a medieval, monastic feel. The East Village bar has murals of monks and is known for being very quiet, making it good for intimate conversation.

• Price: $$
• Cuisine: Bar / Belgian Beer
• Location: 41 E 7th St, New York
• Contact: +1 212-982-4576
• Pro Tip: This spot is known as a “silent bar” where patrons are encouraged to speak quietly. Focus on their great Belgian beer selection.

The Wayland

With its rustic wood decor and dim lighting, The Wayland in the East Village has a comfortable farmhouse feel that is great for the season. They are known for great cocktails and seasonal small plates.

• Price: $$
• Cuisine: American / Cocktails
• Location: 109B Avenue C, New York
• Contact: https://www.thewaylandnyc.com | (212) 673-2403 | info@thewaylandnyc.com
• Pro Tip: They often have live music, which adds to the relaxed atmosphere.

The Bowery Hotel Bar & Lobby

The Bowery Hotel’s lobby has a distinct gothic-chic, old-world feel. With its grand fireplace, antique furnishings, and velvet seating, it feels luxurious and a little bit haunted.

• Price: $$$$
• Cuisine: Hotel Bar
• Location: 335 Bowery, New York
• Contact: https://www.theboweryhotel.com | (212) 505-9100 | reservations@bohonyc.com
• Pro Tip: Grab a seat by the fireplace if you can. It is a great spot for a swanky, low-key night.

Dear Irving on Hudson

This rooftop cocktail lounge offers a sleek, modern gothic feel with great city views. The overall ambiance is formal, dark, and a little mysterious.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine: Cocktail Bar / Small Plates
• Location: 310 West 40th Street, New York NY 10018 (40th & 41st floor inside the Aliz Hotel)
• Contact: https://dearirving.com/hudson | (917) 954-4287
• Pro Tip: Make a reservation in advance to get a window table for the skyline views.

Speakeasies & Hidden Bars

Apotheke

This speakeasy is designed to look like a 19th-century apothecary. The cocktails are called “prescriptions” and feature exotic ingredients, making it feel like a clandestine science experiment.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine: Cocktail Bar
• Location: 9 Doyers St, New York
• Contact: https://www.apothekemixology.com | reservations@apothekenomad.com
• Pro Tip: Finding it is part of the fun – it’s tucked away on a crooked street in Chinatown. Reservations are highly recommended.

Please Don’t Tell (PDT)

Another great speakeasy with a cool and mysterious feel. You enter through a vintage phone booth inside Crif Dogs hot dog joint. Once inside, it is a dark, intimate space with expertly crafted cocktails.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine: Speakeasy / Hot Dogs
• Location: 113 St Marks Pl, New York (inside Crif Dogs)
• Contact: http://www.pdtnyc.com | (212) 614-0386
• Pro Tip: Call exactly on the day you want to visit to secure a reservation, as it is notoriously hard to get into.

Attaboy

This top-tier speakeasy has an unmarked door that gives no hint of the dark and highly personalized experience inside. There is no menu; you simply tell the bartender your preferences, and they create a custom cocktail for you.

• Price: $$$
• Cuisine: Cocktail Bar
• Location: 134 Eldridge St, New York
• Contact: https://attaboy.us
• Pro Tip: First come first served basis. Limited reservations available on OpenTable

Looking for More Fall Activities?

Keeping the spooky spirit alive is great for a night out, but the fall season isn’t over yet. If you are looking for a classic autumn day trip, many local pumpkin patches are still open in early November.

Check out our guide to the 10+ Best Pumpkin Patches Near NYC (Even Without a Car).

More…

• https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Halloween+Restaurant&find_loc=New+York%2C+NY
• https://www.reddit.com/r/halloween/comments/1d3wbrk/halloween_themed_restaurant_in_a_city
• https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowTopic-g60763-i5-k14540101-o10-Best_Restaurant_for_Halloween_Decorations-New_York_City_New_York.html